TITANPOINTE
The NSA’s Spy Hub in New York, Hidden in Plain Sight
Still
from “Project X”
November 16 2016, 7:40 p.m.
THEY CALLED IT Project X. It was an unusually audacious, highly
sensitive assignment: to build a massive skyscraper, capable of withstanding an
atomic blast, in the middle of New York City. It would have no windows, 29
floors with three basement levels, and enough food to last 1,500 people two
weeks in the event of a catastrophe.
But the building’s primary purpose would not be to
protect humans from toxic radiation amid nuclear war. Rather, the fortified
skyscraper would safeguard powerful computers, cables, and switchboards. It
would house one of the most important telecommunications hubs in the United
States — the world’s largest center for processing long-distance phone calls,
operated by the New York Telephone Company, a subsidiary of AT&T.
The building was designed by the architectural firm
John Carl Warnecke & Associates, whose grand vision was to create a
communication nerve center like a “20th century fortress, with spears and
arrows replaced by protons and neutrons laying quiet siege to an army of
machines within.”
Excerpt from “Project X,” a short film by Henrik
Moltke and Laura Poitras, screening at the IFC Center starting Nov. 18. This article is the product of
a joint reporting project between The Intercept and Field of Vision.
Construction began in 1969, and by 1974, the
skyscraper was completed. Today, it can be found in the heart of lower
Manhattan at 33 Thomas Street, a vast gray tower of concrete and granite that
soars 550 feet into the New York skyline. The brutalist structure, still used
by AT&T and, according to the New York Department of Finance, owned by the
company, is like no other in the vicinity. Unlike the many neighboring residential
and office buildings, it is impossible to get a glimpse inside 33 Thomas
Street. True to the designers’ original plans, there are no windows and the
building is not illuminated. At night it becomes a giant shadow, blending into
the darkness, its large square vents emitting a distinct, dull hum that is
frequently drowned out by the sound of passing traffic and wailing sirens.
For many New Yorkers, 33 Thomas Street — known as the
“Long Lines Building” — has been a source of mystery for years. It has been
labeled one of the city’s weirdest and most iconic skyscrapers, but little
information has ever been published about its purpose.
It is not uncommon to keep the public in the dark
about a site containing vital telecommunications equipment. But 33 Thomas
Street is different: An investigation by The Intercept indicates that the
skyscraper is more than a mere nerve center for long-distance phone calls. It
also appears to be one of the most important National Security Agency
surveillance sites on U.S. soil — a covert monitoring hub that is used to tap
into phone calls, faxes, and internet data.
Early model of the entrance of 33 Thomas Street as
designed by John Carl Warnecke & Associates.
Still from “Project X”
Documents obtained by The Intercept from the NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden do not explicitly name 33 Thomas Street as a surveillance facility. However — taken together with architectural plans, public records, and interviews with former AT&T employees conducted for this article — they provide compelling evidence that 33 Thomas Street has served as an NSA surveillance site, code-named TITANPOINTE.
Inside 33 Thomas Street there is a major international
“gateway switch,” according to a former AT&T engineer, which routes phone
calls between the United States and countries across the world. A series of
top-secret NSA memos suggest that the agency has tapped into these calls from a
secure facility within the AT&T building. The Manhattan skyscraper appears
to be a core location used for a controversial NSA surveillance program that
has targeted the communications of the United Nations, the International
Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and at least 38 countries, including close
U.S. allies such as Germany, Japan, and France.
It has long been known that AT&T has cooperated
with the NSA on surveillance, but few details have emerged about the role of specific
facilities in carrying out the top-secret programs. The Snowden documents
provide new information about how NSA equipment has been integrated as part of
AT&T’s network in New York City, revealing in unprecedented detail the
methods and technology the agency uses to vacuum up communications from the
company’s systems.
“This is yet more proof that our communications
service providers have become, whether willingly or unwillingly, an arm of the
surveillance state,” said Elizabeth Goitein, co-director of the liberty and
national security program at the Brennan Center for Justice. “The NSA is
presumably operating under authorities that enable it to target foreigners, but
the fact that it is so deeply embedded in our domestic communications
infrastructure should tip people off that the effects of this kind of
surveillance cannot be neatly limited to non-Americans.”
The NSA declined to comment for this story.
The FBI occupies the entire 23rd floor of 26 Federal
Plaza, seen here behind 33 Thomas Street.
Still from “Project X”
THE CODE NAME TITANPOINTE features dozens of times in the NSA
documents, often in classified reports about surveillance operations. The
agency uses code names to conceal information it deems especially sensitive —
for instance, the names of companies it cooperates with or specific locations
where electronic spying is carried out. Such details are usually considered
“exceptionally controlled information,” a category beyond top secret and thus
outside the scope of most of the documents that Snowden was able to obtain.
Secret NSA travel guides, dated April 2011 and February 2013, however, reveal information about TITANPOINTE that
helps establish its connection to 33 Thomas Street. The 2011 guide, written to
assist NSA employees visiting various facilities, discloses that TITANPOINTE is
in New York City. The 2013 guide states that a “partner” called LITHIUM, which
is NSA’s code name for AT&T, supervises visits to the site.
The 33 Thomas Street building is located almost next
door to the FBI’s New York field office — about a block away — at Federal
Plaza. The 2011 NSA travel guide instructs employees traveling to TITANTPOINTE
to head to the FBI’s New York field office. It adds that trips to the site
should be coordinated with AT&T (referenced as “LITHIUM”) and the FBI,
including an FBI “site watch officer.”
Intercom at 33 Thomas Street.
Still from “Project X”
When traveling to TITANPOINTE, NSA employees are told
to hire a “cover vehicle” through the FBI, especially if they are transporting
equipment to the site. In order to keep their true identities secret while
visiting, agency employees are instructed not to wear any clothing displaying
NSA badges or insignia.
Upon arrival at TITANPOINTE, the 2011 travel guide
says, agency employees should ring the buzzer, sign in, and wait for a person
to come and meet them. The Intercept visited 33 Thomas Street and found a
buzzer outside its entrance and a sign-in sheet on a desk in the building’s
lobby, which is manned by a guard 24 hours a day. There are also parking bays
in front of the skyscraper designated “AWM,” a traffic code for federal agencies.
A 1994 New York Times article reported that 33 Thomas Street was part of
AT&T’s “giant Worldwide Intelligent Network, which is responsible for
directing an average of 175 million phone calls a day.” Thomas Saunders, a
former AT&T engineer, told The Intercept that inside the building there
were at least three “4ESS switches” used to route calls across phone networks.
“Of the first two, one handled domestic long-distance traffic and the other was
an international gateway,” said Saunders, who retired from his role at the
company in 2004. The NSA’s documents describeTITANPOINTE as containing “foreign gateway switches”
and they state that it has a “RIMROCK access.” RIMROCK is an NSA code name for
4ESS switches.
The NSA’s documents also reveal that one of
TITANPOINTE’s functions is to conduct surveillance as part of a program called
SKIDROWE, which focuses on intercepting satellite communications. That is a
particularly striking detail, because on the roof of 33 Thomas Street there are
a number of satellite dishes. Federal Communications Commission records confirm
that 33 Thomas Street is the only location in New York City where AT&T
has an FCC license for satellite earth stations.
Design plan for the tower mechanical
equipment floor at 33 Thomas Street.
THE MAN BEHIND the design of 33 Thomas Street, John Carl
Warnecke, was one of the most prominent architects in the U.S. between the
1960s and 1980s.
Warnecke’s high-profile projects included producing
designs for the U.S. Naval Academy in Maryland, the Hart Senate Office Building
in Washington, D.C., and the Hawaii State Capitol. In 1962, President John F.
Kennedy’s administration commissioned Warnecke to preserve and restructure
buildings at Lafayette Square, across from the White House. And following
Kennedy’s assassination, Warnecke was asked to design the president’s eternal
flame and gravesite at Arlington National Cemetery. He also helped construct a
new embassy complex in Washington for the Soviet Union, in which the Soviets
claimed they found eavesdropping equipment embedded in the walls.
But it was not only governments that trusted Warnecke
— who died in 2010, aged 91 — with major construction projects. He cultivated a
close relationship with telecommunications companies, too, possibly helped by
family ties to the industry. Warnecke’s father-in-law had been a director at
Pacific Bell, a California-based AT&T subsidiary. In the 1960s, Warnecke
was asked to design a telephone exchange building for Pacific Bell in Oakland.
He would subsequently receive a series of other major commissions from
AT&T: Aside from the 33 Thomas Street building, he also designed a
telephone exchange in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and an AT&T facility in
Bedminster, New Jersey.
Some of Warnecke’s original architectural drawings for
33 Thomas Street are labeled “Project X.” It was alternatively referred to as
the Broadway Building. His plans describe the structure as “a skyscraper to be
inhabited by machines” and say that it was “designed to house long lines
telephone equipment and to protect it and its operating personnel in the event
of atomic attack.” (At the time the building was commissioned and built, amid
the Cold War, there were genuine fears in the U.S. about the prospect of a
Soviet nuclear assault.)
Sketch of the plaza at 33 Thomas Street.
It is not clear how many people work at 33 Thomas
Street today, but Warnecke’s original plans stated that it would provide food,
water, and recreation for 1,500 people. It would also store 250,000 gallons of
fuel to power generators, which would enable it to become a “self-contained
city” for two weeks in the event of an emergency power failure. The blueprints for
the building show that it was to include three subterranean levels, including a
cable vault, where telecommunications cables likely entered and exited the
building from under Manhattan’s bustling streets.
After it was built, the unusual style of 33 Thomas
Street attracted a lot of attention. Its dark, somewhat dystopian appearance
contrasted dramatically with other buildings in lower Manhattan. Yet it proved
popular, particularly among architecture buffs.
In a 1982 piece in the New York Times, architecture critic Paul
Goldberger praised 33 Thomas Street as “one of the neighborhood’s few pieces of
good modern architecture,” adding that it “blends into its surroundings more
gracefully than does any other skyscraper in this area.”
“Other telephone company buildings from that era,
designed solely for equipment, all look like horrible boxes,” Goldberger told
The Intercept. “This one has an allure of its own to it. … There’s something
about that shape. You see it and you don’t see it at the same time.”
Satellite dishes on top of 33 Thomas Street. At
TITANPOINTE, a program called SKIDROWE intercepts satellite
communications.
Photo: Henrik Moltke
IN 1975, JUST a year after Warnecke’s 33 Thomas Street
building was completed, the NSA became embroiled in one of the biggest scandals
in the U.S. intelligence community’s history. Following revelations about
domestic surveillance operations targeting anti-Vietnam War activists, a
congressional select committee began investigating the alleged abuses.
The inquiry, led by Democratic Sen. Frank Church,
published its findings in April 1976. It concluded that U.S. intelligence
agencies had “invaded individual privacy and violated the rights of lawful
assembly and political expression.” Surveillance programs operated by the NSA
through this period, it was later revealed, had targeted “domestic terrorist
and foreign radical” suspects, including a host of eminent Americans, such as
the civil rights leaders Martin Luther King and Whitney Young, the boxer
Muhammad Ali, Washington Post columnist Art Buchwald, and New York Times
journalist Tom Wicker.
The Church Committee recommended that new and tighter
controls be placed on intelligence gathering. And in 1978, Congress approved
the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, requiring the executive branch to
request warrants for spying operations from a newly formed court.
Diagrams showing NSA-controlled equipment inside
TITANPOINTE.
Document: NSA
Through this tumultuous time for American spies, the
NSA established a new surveillance program under the code name BLARNEY, which
was first exposed in a Snowden-leaked slide published in 2013. According
to a previously unpublished document provided to The Intercept by Snowden,
BLARNEY was established in the early 1970s and, in mid-2013, remained one of
the agency’s most significant initiatives.
BLARNEY leverages “commercial partnerships” in order
to “gain access and exploit foreign intelligence obtained from global
networks,” the document states. It carries out “full take” surveillance — a term
that refers to the bulk collection of both content and metadata — under six
different categories: counterproliferation, counterterrorism, diplomatic,
economic, military, and political.
As of July 2010, the NSA had obtained at least 40 court orders for spying under the BLARNEY program, allowing
the agency to monitor communications related to multiple countries, companies,
and international organizations. Among the approved targets were the
International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the Bank of Japan, the European
Union, the United Nations, and at least 38 different countries, including U.S.
allies such as Italy, Japan, Brazil, France, Germany, Greece, Mexico, and
Cyprus.
The program was the NSA’s leading source of data
collection under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, an April 2013
document disclosed, and information gleaned from the communications it
intercepted was a top contributor to the president’s daily briefing.
Notably, TITANPOINTE has played a central role in
BLARNEY’s operations. NSA documents dated between 2012 and 2013 list the
TITANPOINTE surveillance facility among three of BLARNEY’s “core sites” and
describe it as “BLARNEY’S site in NYC.” Equipment hosted at TITANPOINTE has
been used to monitor international long-distance phone calls, faxes, voice
calls routed over the internet (known as Voice-Over-IP), video conferencing,
and other internet traffic.
In one case that may have involved 33 Thomas Street,
NSA engineers with the BLARNEY program worked to eavesdrop on data from a
connection serving the United Nations mission in New York. This spying resulted
in “collection against the email address of the U.N. General leading the monitoring
mission in Syria,” an April 2012 memo said.
Mogens Lykketoft, former president of the U.N.’s
general assembly, criticized the surveillance. “Such spying activities are
totally unacceptable breaches of trust in international cooperation,” he told
The Intercept.
Logo for the NSA’s satellite communications
exploitation program SKIDROWE.
NSA
At the TITANPOINTE site, the NSA equipment is stored
inside a secure room, known as a “Sensitive Compartmented Information
Facility.” Top-secret diagrams dated April 2012 show that within the secure
space there is “NSA controlled” equipment linked to the routers of its “access
partner,” referring to AT&T. Intercepted internet data was collected from
the “backbone,” then processed at TITANPOINTE, before being passed to NSA for
storage. Phone calls that were intercepted were collected from TITANPOINTE’s
“foreign gateway switches” before being routed through the partner’s “call
processor.” They were then forwarded to NSA’s headquarters in Maryland through
an interface shared with the partner.
Much of the surveillance carried out at TITANPOINTE
seems to involve monitoring calls and other communications as they
are being sent across AT&T’s international phone and data cables. But
the site has other capabilities at its disposal. The NSA’s documents indicate
that it is also equipped with powerful satellite antenna — likely the ones
located on the roof of 33 Thomas Street — which monitor information transmitted
through the air.
The SKIDROWE spying program focuses on covertly vacuuming up
internet data — known as “digital network intelligence” — as it is passing
between foreign satellites. The harvested data is then made accessible through
XKEYSCORE, a Google-like mass surveillance system that the NSA’s employees use
to search through huge quantities of information about people’s emails, chats,
Skype calls, passwords, and internet browsing histories.
Fletcher Cook, an AT&T spokesperson, told The
Intercept that the company does not “allow any government agency to connect
directly to or otherwise control our network to obtain our customers’
information. Rather, we simply respond to government requests for information
pursuant to court orders or other mandatory process and, in rare cases, on a
legal and voluntary basis when a person’s life is in danger and time is of the
essence, like in a kidnapping situation.”
Cook added that NSA representatives “do not have access
to any secure room or space within our owned portion of the 33 Thomas Street
building.” When pressed on whether any room within 33 Thomas
Street contains equipment used for the purposes of NSA surveillance, an
AT&T spokesperson pointed to a 1983 deed and declaration filed with New York City indicating that
Verizon’s predecessor company maintained ownership of three floors and a
basement floor in the building. The New York City Department of Finance
said the predecessor company has an easement for the space and pays utility
taxes, but insisted that AT&T owns the whole building. The AT&T
spokesperson declined to comment further.
The NSA’s documents do not state that it can “connect
directly to” or “otherwise control” AT&T’s networks, but they do make clear
that the agency has placed its own equipment inside TITANPOINTE to tap into
phone calls and internet data. It may be the case that the secure room where
the equipment is installed is overseen by AT&T’s own engineers or
technicians who have a security clearance. One NSA document dated from March
2013 suggests such a relationship, noting that the “corporate sites” the
agency collects data from “are often controlled by the partner, who
filters the communications before sending to NSA.”
As in 1983, AT&T may not be completely alone at 33
Thomas Street. Earlier this year, a technician working at the building — who
did not want to be named because he was not authorized to speak to the media —
told The Intercept that a handful of Verizon employees were still based inside.
However, the NSA’s documents do not suggest that Verizon is implicated in the
surveillance at the TITANPOINTE facility, and instead only point
to AT&T’s involvement. Verizon declined to comment for
this story.
The entrance to 33 Thomas Street.
Still from “Project X”
AT&T IS FAR from the only company that has a relationship
with the NSA. The agency has established what it calls “strategic partnerships”
with more than 80 corporations. But some companies are more cooperative than
others.
Historically, AT&T has always maintained close
ties with the government. A good example of this came in June 1976, when a
congressional subcommittee served AT&T with a subpoena demanding that it
hand over information about its alleged role in unlawful FBI wiretapping of
phone calls. President Gerald Ford personally intervened to block the subpoena,
stating that AT&T “was and is an agent of the United States acting under
contract with the Executive Branch.” Ford said the company was in a “unique
position” with respect to telephone and other communication lines in the U.S.,
and therefore it had been “necessary for the Executive Branch to rely on its
services to assist in acquiring certain information necessary to the national
defense and foreign policy.” The details sought by the committee could not be shared,
Ford asserted, because they could expose “extremely sensitive foreign
intelligence and counterintelligence information.”
In more recent decades, as the New York Times and
ProPublica reportedlast year, AT&T has allowed the NSA to access
billions of emails, exhibiting what the agency called its “extreme willingness
to help.” These revelations were foreshadowed in 2006 by allegations made by
Mark Klein, a former AT&T technician. Klein stated that the company had
maintained a “secure room” in one of its San Francisco offices, which was
fitted with communications monitoring equipment apparently used by the NSA to
tap into phone and internet traffic. Klein’s claims formed the basis of a
lawsuit brought by the Electronic Frontier Foundation on behalf of AT&T
customers (Jewel v. NSA), which remains ongoing today.
Mark Klein at 33 Thomas Street in 1988. Klein worked
as an AT&T employee at that location for 10 years.
Photo courtesy of Mark Klein
Coincidentally, between 1981 and 1990, Klein also
worked for AT&T at 33 Thomas Street. “I wasn’t aware of any NSA presence
when I was there, but I had a creepy feeling about the building, because I knew
about AT&T’s close collaboration with the Pentagon, going way back,” he
told The Intercept. When presented with the details linking 33 Thomas Street to
NSA’s TITANPOINTE, Klein added: “I’m not surprised. It’s obviously a major
installation. … If you’re interested in doing surveillance, it’s a good place
to do it.”
According to the Snowden documents, AT&T has
installed surveillance equipment in at least 59 U.S. sites. And on any
given day, NSA employees may be working at the company’s facilities. Classified
memos dated from April 2013 describe one- to four-day deployments of NSA
technical staff to TITANPOINTE and other buildings. Most AT&T personnel at
these locations, however, are unlikely to have knowledge of the agency’s
presence. NSA staff are encouraged to wear clothes that make them “blend in to
the environment.” Even the car hire company the agency uses for its trips to
AT&T facilities is kept in the dark. “Some personnel are aware of the FBI
link,” states the agency’s travel guidance, “but [they] have no knowledge of
NSA’s involvement.”
This article is the product of a joint reporting
project between The Intercept and Field of Vision. “Project X,” a Field of
Vision documentary directed by Henrik Moltke and Laura Poitras, will screen at
IFC Center starting November 18.
———
———
Documents published with this story:
- BLARNEY
site book
- FAIRVIEW
site book
- FAIRVIEW
dataflow charts April 2012
- Special
Source Operations corporate overview
- BLARNEY
report April 2013
- BLARNEY
program overview
- SKIDROWE
program
CONTACT
THE AUTHOR:
/https://www.niagarafallsreview.ca/content/dam/thestar/news/canada/2021/09/25/huawei-executive-meng-wanzhou-receives-warm-welcome-upon-return-to-china/_1_meng_wanzhou_2.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.